Windows Live Mail 2012. When I reply to a message, the person receives the response, BUT when I go to my sent mail items, I only see the original message not what I typed as a reply. If I log into hotmail.com and check the sent items there, everything is fine (I see the original message and my response).

Save copy of Sent messages in the Sent items folder is already checked. Windows live recognizes that I sent a message, it just isn't including what I typed.